Pitchfork reviewed the Babies album today, one that I have been obsessively listening to for the past six months. The thing about it is, I feel like much of this album’s purpose has been lost in the writeup. Of course the critic has already dismissed me by implying that I probably like the band because of who is in it, not due to their music’s credit. Maybe. But I listen to the album way too much on my own to really believe it’s for such an external reason. I really believe in this album. Here are my reasons why you should give it a chance.

The Babies album possesses an earnest depth in it’s messiness that has been completely lacking from most recent indie rock. Personally, I’ve grown so tired of the irony and detachment that’s overwhelmed the sub-genre. The Babies provide an antidote to that tiring trend with their forthright vulnerability.
The Babies aren’t singing about boyfriends, girlfriends, parties or twee desire, they are, on a deeper listen, singing about existential crisis. Through the album, I feel as if I’m following the Babies two vocalists as I would follow Orpheus, leading me down through the afterlife while they try not to look over their shoulder. The uncertain vocals that Pitchfork complains of are, in my mind, completely purposeful… in the same way that the best French New Wave directors hired plaintive, simple speaking actors who did not seem to be acting to convey the lost purpose in modern life, the Babies, through their sometimes wavering voices, demonstrate to us the uncertainty at the heart of coping with powerlessness.
”The Babies” possesses cohesion, with each song connecting back to a stage of mourning. We begin by exploring a determination to rediscover the thrills that begin to escape us as we age (Somebody Else, Meet me in the City,) the fearful anticipation of the inevitability of death (All Things Come to Pass, Sick Kid in the Distance, The War) and the impossibility of ever really coping as our friends are taken from us (Wild I and II, Breaking the Law).
On “All Things Come to Pass,” it seems like Cassie’s trying to convince herself, and us, that she’s over death— she’s not afraid. But there is a sharp edge of despair to it. Cassie and Kevin are not our typical indie rock protagonists telling a simple story. This story is rife with doubt and denial. “Don’t be sad when it’s over and done, days go on like a loaded gun.” Her voice takes on a demanding quality— she’s not telling us this because she is over it, but precisely because she CAN’T get over it. Every day brings the possibility of the irreproachable final bullet. The next song on the album is our evidence. She murmurs— “Yesterday someone I used to know. And now they’re gone and they’re gone for good.” Kevin tells us “this heart is broken and this heart is torn.” As if to flee this unfurling despair, the Babies hit us over the head with “Meet me in the City.” It’s a manic escape— compensation for the sorrow, confusion and pain. The following tune increases it’s panicked mania with even more fervor and despair. Then, suddenly, nostalgia in “Breaking the Law”… remembering the safety we once found alongside each other before we knew the risks, that we can’t seem to find anymore.
I’ve never heard an album that so opens it’s heart and reveals the personal complications that surround loss without any sense of melodrama. The exhaustion of pain, the despair that accompanies our drive to lose ourselves in thrill seeking, the satisfying break that comes when we finally acknowledge our inescapable agony (Wild II.)
I love the Babies not because, as Pitchfork implies, I am charmed by the members, but because I have experienced the obsessive despair that the album outlines. The mania and fear that surrounds us after we lose someone. The fearful awareness that we, ourselves, are also hurled towards eventually devastating those we love. The push and pull, the un-spooling thoughts that draw us into obsessing about our own inevitable departure as we mourn someone, while denying the depth of our despair. The optimism when we finally re-approach life, having come through the turmoil of death’s foretaste.
The Babies speak to the reality of my early adulthood more than any other album in my life right now. I have pushed against my responsibilities, fled from my feelings, and now, near twenty-seven, am beginning to accept the darkness that surrounds us as we age and let go of one another, and hopefully learn to embrace what we can, and cannot, control.